The Nestlerest house among oak trees, an undated nineteenth- or early twentieth-century photograph
Lake Zurich, Illinois · 1841 to today

Nestlerest
& Isaac Fox

A lakeshore house that outlasted a glassmaker's fortune, a case in the United States Supreme Court, a summer boarding house and half a century of company picnics. It still stands at 40 Mischa Court.

Section 20 · T43N R10ETraditionally c. 1859Preserved 2009
The Nestlerest house. Undated photograph, Ela Historical Society / Ela Area Public Library.
Scroll
The story in brief

A house at the center of a changing lake

On the south shore of Lake Zurich, the building now known as 40 Mischa Court carries several histories at once. It is associated with the family of Isaac Willard Fox, whose business connected the lake to the glassworks of New York and the commercial streets of Chicago. It survived a family financial dispute that reached the United States Supreme Court.

It belongs, too, to the story of Flora and Frank Clark, summer boarders, ice harvesting, picnic crowds and the Lake Zurich Queen. Its modern address is the newest layer over a much older place.

This site gathers that history from court opinions, an 1891 title abstract, newspapers, maps, photographs and village records — and is careful to say where the evidence is firm and where it is still being sought.

Postcard view of Nestlerest on Lake Zurich among mature trees
“Nestlerest on Lake Zurich, Lake Zurich, Ill.” — c. 1913
1857
I. Willard Fox buys about 535 acres from Charles Starr for $8,600
1889
Goodwin v. Fox is decided by the U.S. Supreme Court
1898
“The Hermit” is renamed Nestlerest Cottage
2009
The park becomes Lake Zurich Oaks — and the house is kept
How to read this history

One place, many layers

A document about the large farm does not automatically prove a fact about the park — or about the particular building that survives. The research keeps these layers apart.

Contemporary recordRetrospective / local historyProvisional / in conflict

Small source tags like link to the full source list. Hover or focus one to see what it is.

i

The Lake Zurich farm

Parts of Sections 17, 18 and 20, Township 43 North, Range 10 East — roughly 535 acres in the 1857 deed.

ii

Goodwin's Subdivision

The west 10 chains 75 links of the SW¼ of the NW¼ of Section 20 — Kate W. Goodwin's lots.

iii

Nestlerest Park

104 Robertson Avenue — summer cottage, picnic grove and amusement park, 1898–2004.

iv

The surviving house

40 Mischa Court, Lake Zurich Oaks Lot 2 — a four-unit home, likely built as a single-family house before 1900.

v

Working parcel reference

PIN 14-20-106-025 — from property-data sources; verify with the county.

Its history connects an industrial family, a civic land gift, a widow and her children, village incorporation, ice production, summer boarding, company picnics, and a deliberate decision to preserve an old building.From the research synthesis, October 2026
Today

The house from above

The former Nestlerest grounds are now Lake Zurich Oaks, an eight-lot subdivision on about 4.7 acres. The old house sits on Lot 2, a short walk from the shore it has faced for more than a century and a half.

Live satellite view. The dashed outline is a reconstruction of Kate W. Goodwin's Subdivision from its tax description — not a survey.